A nine-country survey of 1,217 IT professionals reveals that enterprises worldwide believe they are realising value from their IT investments—yet they cannot be sure, as fewer than half have a shared understanding of value across the enterprise, and two-thirds fail to fully measure it.
 
Conducted by ISACA, an association of 86,000 IT governance, security and assurance professionals, the Value of IT Investments survey found that half of the respondents believe they are realising between 50-74 percent of expected value from their IT investments, and nearly a fifth believe they are realising 75-100 percent. Yet, half measure the actual value only “to some extent,” while one in 10 does not measure it at all.
 
Paul Williams, IT Strategy Chair and IT governance adviser to Protiviti UK stated, “this survey illustrates the massive potential for value destruction from ill considered IT related business investments. The lack of value measurement can lead to misleading and unreliable business cases and the consequent approval of discretionary projects that are unlikely to add to value creation. A more robust approach to all aspects of IT investment governance can lead directly to improved financial and operational performance”.
 
At the same time, half of the respondents reported that accountability for such value measurements is delegated to the IT function itself, instead of remaining with the business, where it belongs. Full results of the survey can be obtained by contacting news@isaca.org.
 
John Thorp, chair of the Val IT Development Team for ISACA and president of the Thorp Network, commented, “The results of this survey reinforce findings from earlier studies that, while most enterprises feel they are realising value from IT, few have a clear understanding of what value means, and even fewer measure it. This raises the question, ‘On what basis are spending decisions made?’ Additionally, enterprises that do not fully measure value are unable to determine which investments are successful and which need to be cut—and thereby are likely to miss out on revenue-generating opportunities, pursue unsuccessful investments and neglect competitive advantage.”
 
Adds Thorp, “These findings support the results of a number of other studies, anecdotal evidence and my own experience that most decisions related to value from IT are subjective, and all too often are based on perception and emotion rather than on facts. Organisations will not come close to realising the full value of their IT investments until they adopt effective value management practices and assign accountability for the realization of value from those investments to the board and CEO, rather than abdicating it to the CIO.”
 
Thorp’s view regarding the lack of business accountability for value from increasingly significant and complex IT-related investments is reflected in the 49 per cent of respondents stating that the CIO or IT managers are responsible for ensuring that stakeholder returns on such investments are optimized. Only 15 per cent said responsibility lies with the board, 11 percent the CEO and 9 per cent the CFO. Remarkably, 8 per cent said no one was responsible.
 
On a positive note, 76 per cent of respondents are aware of the Val IT framework, and 44 percent of organisations questioned have such a framework or guidelines in place to select the investment that will result in the highest value.
 
Additionally, despite the challenging economy, 30 percent of companies are increasing their investments in IT this year, while only 13 percent plan to reduce spending and 14 percent plan to freeze it at the current level. In the UK this average isn’t replicated, as just 19 percent of organizations intend to increase their investment while 20 percent plan to cut spending across the board.
 
Interestingly, among the benefits organisations receive from their IT-related investments, respondents cited “improved customer service” (35 per cent) and “cost reduction” (24 percent) as the two most important. Somewhat surprisingly, only 16 per cent named “new or improved products and services” as the top benefit. India stands out, with improved customer service as the top-ranked benefit, at 45 per cent.
 
 “Organisations should be careful not to ignore the value-generating opportunities of IT in favor of cost cutting. IT has the power to add competitive advantage and significant business value, so it is critical to focus on those opportunities—particularly in troubled economic times,” said Robert Stroud, CGEIT, international vice president of ISACA. “The implementation of Val IT can help enterprises identify more effective metrics, leading to successful investments in IT projects that better align with the strategic goals of their business.”
 
The survey identified some regional differences—specifically between established economies and fast-growing ones. Of the nine countries surveyed—Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Hong Kong, India, Mexico, the UK and the US—the India-based participants were the most advanced in adopting effective value management practices and assigning accountability for those investments to the business. Seventy per cent of respondents’ organisations in India have a framework for selecting the IT-related investments that will result in the greatest value and 57 percent fully measure value. In addition, almost half of Indian organizations are increasing IT-related investment based on potential or expected contribution to business value, and 63 per cent said there is a cross-departmental understanding of what constitutes value in IT investment—a figure significantly lower in the UK, at just 22 per cent, and the US, at 34 per cent. Top-down management responsibility for optimizing IT investment was also evident, with one-third of respondents indicating board or board chair level.

Other Channel News

Channel Talk

BlueStar Europe appoints new Managing Director BlueStar has appointed Stefan Gerats to the Managing Director post of BlueStar Europe's Central region. Sony signs partnership agreement with ICEcat Sony has announced an extended partnership with ICEcat by including support for 26 European languages and full integration with its own product information management system. Kodak appoints Midwich to broaden distribution in the UK & Ireland Kodak has appointed Midwich to broaden distribution of its networked, workgroup and departmental scanners to over 6,000 IT resellers based in the UK and Ireland. TVision sign as Masternaut Three-X Reseller TVision Technology has signed as a reseller for Masternaut Three X. Psion Teklogix unveils global partner programme to facilitate open innovation Psion Teklogix, Inc. (Psion Teklogix), a global provider of mobile computing solutions, has announced a new global Partner Programme focused on open innovation. Post Office Business Insurance launched for IT consultants The Post Office has launched a specialist business insurance which has been tailored for the UK's 109,000 IT consulting companies. More >>

Damaged laptops cost British business £2.073 billion a year Damaged laptops will cost British business £2.073 billion in repair and data replacement costs in 2010, research from IDC and Panasonic has predicted. Handheld bolsters management team with appointment of new Vice President of Business Development Swedish based Handheld Group has appointed Mike Zelman as their new Vice President of Business Development as the company seeks to continue building a world class organisation and position the company for further international growth. Half of organisations expect cloud to enable creativity and growth The IT Infrastructure Event is due to take place at London's Earls Court this coming September. IT directors give thumbs-down to service providers IT directors are far from happy with the service they receive from their third party IT service providers. More >>